SmallBizGenius Analysis

Carmellimo, a car and limousine service, receives overwhelmingly negative reviews regarding reliability and customer service. Customers frequently report issues with no-shows, late arrivals, and unhelpful or rude drivers, resulting in a very low Trustpilot rating.

Category Breakdown

Scores based on analysis of 96 recent reviews

Reliability (No-Shows & Lateness)

1.0/10

A significant number of reviewers report that their Carmellimo rides either didn't show up at all or arrived significantly late. Many of these were pre-paid bookings, leaving customers stranded at airports or other locations, such as one reviewer who stated, "Carmel lied to us, didn’t show up for a prepaid trip."

42 reviews mention this

Customer Service Issues

1.5/10

Numerous reviewers express dissatisfaction with Carmellimo's customer service, citing unhelpful representatives, lack of communication, and difficulty obtaining refunds. Many report being given false information or ignored when trying to resolve issues, with one reviewer stating, "Non existent customer service...beware because if something goes wrong, they will never take care of it."

35 reviews mention this

Driver Behavior & Professionalism

2.0/10

Several reviewers describe negative experiences with Carmellimo drivers, including rudeness, demands for extra money, and unsafe driving. Some drivers reportedly lacked communication skills or refused to assist with luggage, with one reviewer recounting being "held hostage" over a toll fee.

28 reviews mention this

Vehicle Quality & Cleanliness

2.5/10

A number of reviewers complain about the poor condition and cleanliness of Carmellimo vehicles. Issues include dirty interiors, broken air conditioning, and general disrepair, as one reviewer noted being "Picked up in a filthy, old car with torn upholstery and broken air conditioning."

10 reviews mention this

Pricing & Hidden Fees

3.0/10

Some reviewers report unexpected charges and discrepancies in pricing, with drivers demanding additional payments for tolls or tips. Several customers felt they were overcharged or misled about the total cost of their ride, with one reviewer describing the company as "Predatory."

12 reviews mention this

Positive Experiences

4.0/10

A small number of reviewers report positive experiences with Carmellimo, praising punctual drivers, clean cars, and overall good service. These reviewers found the service reliable and convenient, as one reviewer stated, "Always on time.. great drivers.. easy".

15 reviews mention this

Pros & Cons

What Customers Love

Some drivers are punctual and provide good service. Mentioned 10x
"Arrived on time and great car, excellent service and price was competitive."
Easy to make reservations. Mentioned 3x
"Easy making reservation, on time pickup, smooth and perfect ride to EWR, friendly and helpful driver. I always count on Carmel to get me where I need to go and when."
Competitive pricing compared to other car services (when the price is honored). Mentioned 4x
"On time best price clean comfortable: Car arrived ahead of time was extremely comfortable and clean, driver pleasant, The price was better than other car services in NYC."

Common Complaints

Frequent no-shows and late arrivals leave customers stranded. Mentioned 42x
"Carmel lied to us, didn’t show up for a prepaid trip."
Poor customer service with unhelpful and unresponsive representatives. Mentioned 35x
"Their customer service is horrible.!!! beware because if something goes wrong, they will never take care of it"
Drivers are often rude, unprofessional, and demand extra money. Mentioned 28x
"Went to meet my car and the driver didn't even say hello... just immediately said the prices have all gone up and started asking for more money."
Vehicles are often dirty, old, and in disrepair. Mentioned 10x
"Picked up in a filthy, old car with torn upholstery and broken air conditioning."
Unexpected charges and hidden fees lead to overbilling. Mentioned 12x
"Please stop demanding tips for a trip which has already been paid for in advance."

Common Questions About Carmellimo

Answers derived from customer review patterns

Is Carmellimo legit and trustworthy?

Based on 96 reviews, Carmellimo appears to be unreliable and not trustworthy for many customers. A significant number of reviewers report pre-paid rides not showing up, drivers arriving late or not at all, and difficulties in obtaining refunds. While some customers have positive experiences, the overwhelming negative sentiment suggests that Carmellimo is a risky choice.

Based on 45 reviews

Does Carmellimo have good customer service?

The majority of reviews indicate that Carmellimo's customer service is poor. Customers frequently report unhelpful representatives, lack of communication, and difficulty resolving issues. Many reviewers express frustration with the company's inability to address their concerns or provide timely assistance.

Based on 35 reviews

Is Carmellimo worth it for small business?

Given the high number of negative reviews concerning reliability and customer service, Carmellimo is likely not a worthwhile option for small businesses needing dependable transportation. The risk of no-shows, late arrivals, and unprofessional drivers outweighs any potential cost savings. Small businesses should consider alternative transportation services with more consistent positive feedback.

Based on 50 reviews